Zac Efron took a walk to remember in “The Lucky One”
Comments: 3 - Date: April 26th, 2012 - Categories: movie review
By Kayla Cohen
“The Lucky One,” is the story of a sergeant in the Marines, Logan (played by Zac Efron,) who finds a photograph of a beautiful girl named Beth (played by Taylor Schilling) in the rubble after a night raid. After keeping the photo as a good luck charm, and narrowly escaping death on numerous occasions, Logan promises himself he is going to find that woman and thank her for saving his life. And that is exactly what he does.
Like most of the Nicholas Sparks’ novels turned into films, “The Lucky One” does stray a bit from the original storyline.
In the novel, the photograph of Beth is with two men in front of a ferris wheel. Also, the back of the photo says “Keep Safe, E.” In the film, Beth is standing by herself with a lighthouse in the distance and the back of the photo says “Keep Safe, X.”
The location also differs. In the novel, the story takes place in North Carolina, but in the movie it is located in Louisiana.
A huge difference is that in the novel Logan’s dog saves Beth’s son’s life, but in the movie the son is saved by his father.
My only big complaint is that the film also lacks the chemistry between the main characters as shown in the novel. The lack of intimate scenes is understandable, since the rating was PG-13. But, this film just didn’t show the heart-wrenching chemistry like in the other Sparks’ movies. Efron and Schilling’s romance just didn’t cut it this time.
Is “The Lucky One” one of Nicholas Sparks’ best adaptations? Sadly not. But then again, every movie can’t have a love like in “The Notebook.”
3 Responses
jfarley2 - April 26, 2012 @ 8:11 pm
I think you are spot on with this review. While I haven’t seen this film, I’ve had a hard time appreciating any Nicholas Sparks adaptations following The Notebook. But, this story line sounds interesting nonetheless!
smason7 - May 1, 2012 @ 12:33 am
I am a HUGE Nicholas Sparks fan. Unfortunately, I didn’t manage to read the novel before seeing the movie, and like many books turn into movies, I was just hoping it wouldn’t be the same and “ruin” the experience. I think you did a good job comparing both to one another in the length that you did. I will admit that when I first started reading your review, I was a bit nervous because I didn’t want to know anything even though I had already seen the film. But good job basically leaving the reader on the edge of their seat. Gets me more excited to read the book now. And so far, I’ve loved everything he’s written. I didn’t think it was possible to go wrong with his story lines.
Search
Archives
Categories
Blogroll